No Bullshit Clan

NoBS|Public Lounge => Lounge => Topic started by: Indy on October 09, 2008, 01:36:10 AM

Title: Hello :)
Post by: Indy on October 09, 2008, 01:36:10 AM
Im Indy, im a Canadian citizen. As such i have a nice unbiassed view of the way your country works. I take great interest in the way your country works, or as i look at it, fails. Now im not saying americans are failures or anything, but alot of things about your country, mainly the government are fail.

Id like to bring to the debate table... your income tax. :)

Now, i have a few movies you can watch, but you most likely wont watch them... You American's generally dont like to learn truths, half or whole about your country.

First, it is nessecary to understand the definition of income. Supreme court states, income is defined by gains by corporations and or profits of any kind.

So income tax = Tax on Gains. So corporations paying income tax is completely legal BY your constitution. It is not legal to tax wages. They are not gains but a service being paid for, bartering, (Also ruled by a supreme court). A worker works for the business owner and is compensated. That is now your private property, and illegal to tax.

Infact, the supreme court has ruled 100% of the time in favour of anyone being charged with this tax. Many small cases with juries have also acquitted on the grounds that neither the irs, government, judge or prosecutor can provide the law rquiring you to pay your income taxes.

There is actually no legal obligation nor any law requiring you to file your 1040 or pay income tax. What it says in your internal revenue code i believe its called states its voluntary, not mandatory. Why you may ask is this tax which you pay and can be arrested for voluntary to pay? Because there is no law stating you must pay it.

If you do not pay your taxes, and are charged, you have a high % of beating those charges, and basically a 100% chance with a jury. Appeal to the supreme court if you have to, you will eventually be acquitted.

I have forgotten some things, but basically thats the jist, i wont even go into how your money is completely worthless being legal tender and not redeemable in gold like your dollar bill used to say, nor the fact that your federal reserve is a private bank in which the owners make huge profits off of taxes.


Arguements against these facts can be brought to light as well. The 16th amendment gives the right to charge this tax. Wrong. The supreme court ruled numerous times that the 16th amendment does not give any power to levy a new tax. You didnt have to pay the income tax before the 16th and still do not have to pay it now. Thats basically it. All anyone on the opposing side has said because their is no logical nor reasonable rebutled to this arguement as the tax is facticious in nature.

Here are the movie links, you can watch zeitgeist or http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1656880303867390173 <- America: freedom to facism.

You guys dont like to expand your minds i know, but i am telling you that you do not legally have to pay your income tax. It is your right as defined by the constitution and income is completely unconstitutional.

I mean no disrespect to any of you by saying all this nor my next statement, but this is to be debated hopefully in a calm and collected manner.




Id like to finish with a story.

A man named joe lewis. An american hero and icon. Won 27 fights and knocked out german mac shmelling who represented hitlers arian idols and won him admiration of millions of americans admiration in 1938. He donated his fee for a title fight to navy relief fund, right after pearl harbor was bombed, which was alot of money. He joined the segregated his army while defending his title, and gave this fee to the army relief. Since the cheques were in his name he was taxed full ammount for it. Even though he never saw a penny of it. He was awarded the legion of merit at the end of war. But he was being charged 50,000 a year in interest alone. When his mother died leaving him 600$ the IRS confiscated it and his childrens trust funds. He fought till he was 37 and out of shape to pay off his debt, which was $1,000,000 with 100,000 in interest. He was forced to become a greeter at the end of his life just to make ends meat.

Pretty bad. Debate?
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: SimonVI on October 09, 2008, 08:17:34 AM
yer indy people these daysdont have time to read you life story lol
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: werth on October 09, 2008, 08:59:36 AM
we have income tax in canada too..

as far as those movies.. more whackjobs conspiracy theorists.... ill watch them.. probably another full-of-holes and deeply misinforming... but ill watch em and see
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: Riggs on October 09, 2008, 10:59:22 AM
Dont be an Idiot, a supreme court ruling can be looked up at any time, why would they say the 16th doesnt give any power to income tax and aquit people who are charged with the tax?

Why can nobody find the law.

If you can find the law in the american law books indy will donate $1,000 dollars to the server
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: werth on October 09, 2008, 11:07:32 AM
i didnt say it wasnt true to be honest i have no clue about income tax in the states... nor do i really care.... but a movie that claims 9/11 was a hoax is pretty non-credible in my books... kind of borders insanity...

but ill watch it and see
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: Evilgenius on October 09, 2008, 12:18:47 PM
omg this is sooooooooooooooooooooo old .  point blank you pay taxes or you dont use the schools, roads, government aids, emergency services, military, etc

what would you do?

hey someone just shot your mother but you didnt pay taxes so the cops dont give a fuck. 

some country launched a nuke at you but all you can do is watch it fall.

your kids need to goto college but there is no grants to do so.


expand that

Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: Indy on October 09, 2008, 03:28:29 PM
I did like 0 research into what taxes go where, so im gonna have to quote the movie. Income tax pays for none of those things, they are paid for by other taxes i believe.

Cops still must still do an investigation, they can not deny that.

The military is funded by income taxes though, but apparently the ammount of money from corporate income taxes are an = value to what the military is given. Says that movie i have nothing else backing that other then this so im iffy on that one.

You pay hundreds of taxes on everything evil, i cannot believe that you list those 3 things like income tax pays for them, what do your other taxes pay for?

If you have a credible source stating which taxes go where or even can tell me specifically where income tax is supposed to be going when it goes back to the people can you link it so i can see?

I know the income tax is supposed to be apportionated being a direct tax. Thats your law.
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: werth on October 09, 2008, 04:35:49 PM
I did like 0 research into what taxes go where, so im gonna have to quote the movie.
exactly. do some research

If you have a credible source stating which taxes go where or even can tell me specifically where income tax is supposed to be going when it goes back to the people can you link it so i can see?
start with your credible source. not some C list shoddy conspiracy theorist movie. taxes fund a lot of things, and some are necessary.
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: KU@TO on October 09, 2008, 05:22:46 PM
start with your credible source. not some C list shoddy conspiracy theorist movie. taxes fund a lot of things, and some are necessary.


Agreed,  get some reliable sources first.  Can't expect to have a respectful debate when you go on a rant citing some videos you found on youtube as your sources... 

As a matter of background, here are some things as I understand them about the US & Canadian economies.  I'm not an economist and I wrote this really fast so feel free to correct me if I'm wrong:

For decades, the US of A was the wealthiest nation and those with the highest levels of education (plus experience) where getting phenomenal jobs in Silicon Valley, the Texas Triangle, and the Northeast Corridor (Boston-to-Richmond). True, the era from 1945 to 1995 was the age of the brain drain not only in the US, it was a vast majority of the nations of the world. Today, that core American research and development has been sent off shore and unlike Canada, the US is not an export driven economy; it's an economy based upon the principles of borrow and spend by all parties (banks, treasury, citizens, etc) with other nations in east Asia and the middle east. [In essence, if Canada so wanted, it could put all of its non-export economy citizens on welfare, and provided that east Asians bought Canadian minerals and oil, could sustain itself for a long time.] All and all, what happened was that everyone had forgotten about the depression and thought that one could live the American dream through CCs, speculation on markets, and the HELOC. In contrast, Canadians were a lot more circumspect, having limited experience with the so-called good times, and saved more than the typical American.

So this brings us to the financial meltdown we're in today.  In their infinite wisdom our politicians made sure that the US taxpayers once again take it in the ass and come to the rescue in the form of a 700+b bill.  As much as I fucking hate it(the DOW crashed right after the massive bailout passed), it may be the only serious option. There isn't a whole lot else we could have done anymore because of the credit freeze. It shouldn't be the whole solution, but not doing anything could cause more banks to fail. As more banks here fail, the web of international finance begins to collapse. Banks in Russia are already failing, and Putin is using US Treasury securities to finance his bailout plan. That means that Putin is selling off US debt, such a flood of US debt on the securities market will depress the value of the dollar, only heightening our problems. I'm not quite sure about this next part yet, and it depends on a severely depressed dollar, but it does seem very plausible as a worst case scenario: a cheap dollar makes the things we import much more expensive. With the primarily manufacturing-based Chinese economy already on the brink due to the financial situation spreading overseas they need that trade, but it won't happen because the goods are now relatively expensive compared to US manufactured goods. This causes more financial problems in China, potentially leading to even more banks failing. It is not too far outside of a sure thing to assume that China will follow Russia's example and finance some form of a bailout by selling some of the billions in US interests that it holds, thereby further depressing the value of the dollar, and entrenching us farther into this crisis.

How it affects Canada:
Canada's economy is tied to the US since America is the largest importer of Canadian goods(http://dataweb.usitc.gov/scripts/cy_m3_run.asp), so any slip in the American economy sends shock waves through Canada's counterpart. The rise of the value of the Canadian dollar when compared to the American has created a lot of fear in both the Canadian tourism and export business. A lot of people won't have jobs if Americans can't afford continue trading Canadian goods. However I'm optimistic our markets will recover.

Canadian taxes:
In my view, the taxes code in Canada is atrocious though not as bad as some European nations.  A consequence in part of your ever expanding government and costly health and social entitlement programs.  Also, most goods (maybe all, don't hold me to this) are taxed both the Canadian sales tax and the provincial sales tax (AFAIK some provinces don't have a provincial sales tax, but Quebec does. ) and their cost adds up quickly. I don't have any experience with estate taxes, property taxes, etc., but if the have any sort of equivalence to the cost of sales taxes then we can assume they're expensive. 

If you want to bring defense spending into the discussion, then that's opening a can of worms.  ie Canada piggybacking on the US.   That's just going to make me write another boring long-winded post. ;)
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: werth on October 09, 2008, 07:40:15 PM
we have provincial sales tax in every province except for alberta i believe. the federal GST tax was at 7% for the longest time, and harper downed it to 6% and now 5% in the last 2 1/2 years. good on him.. of course this doesnt bode well with NDP and liberals and the likes, because they thrive on taxing taxing and more taxing to fund those ever growing social programs and ridiculous plans for carbon tax.

i guess its just how you look at it... more taxes, more revenue for the government, less personal spending? or less taxes, which means more disposable income for citizens to make they're own choices. ill go with the latter. im fear the day (soon) that we'll be under NDP leadership... they're stock is rising every day. Im not too worried about the Greens. A few years from now, when we realize that our world is not coming to an end (what was it 2010 or 2012 elizabeth may said? LOL) their novelty will wear off. Im not sure who would vote for the Greens, oh thats right.. the tree hugging hippie fags... i guess they missed the memo (she thinks you're stupid)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9FGfVKay8o
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: Riggs on October 10, 2008, 01:33:55 PM
The day the green party controls our government will be the day the world ends (im all for the leagilaztion of marijuana, but they offer litterally nothing for our community)
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: werth on October 10, 2008, 02:33:11 PM
The day the green party controls our government will be the day the world ends (im all for the leagilaztion of marijuana, but they offer litterally nothing for our community)
youre getting parties mixed up. green party equals environment. marijuana party equals marijuana. alot of people confuse the two
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: smitty1258 on October 10, 2008, 03:17:15 PM
Im with K@uto and his book.

I however try not to get to wrapped up into it, #1 The odds of a major collapse are very small, I would be willing to guess less than 1%. The major problem I see, which is the same problem we always have had, is that the rich get richer. Id also be willing to guess many worked to get that way, and worked hard.

I guess the most postive thing I can say about all of it, if the shit hits the fan and a collapse happens, dont come to my house, youll be taking the short route out. Im ready, are you?
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: werth on October 10, 2008, 03:20:40 PM
"the fundamentals of our economy are strong" lol :P
no but really although we're seeing the whiplash of your shit... we're still fine, and will be fine. real question is, if shit hits the fan, you gonna pack your shit and come to canada eh? igloo's are cheap. all you need is water
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: Sounds on October 10, 2008, 03:39:53 PM
honestly the only thing i've noticed here is cheaper gas, and in general, cheaper everything.
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: werth on October 10, 2008, 04:34:10 PM
gas went to under 1$/litre the other day.. feels good to finally fill up and not bend over the same time.

man i wish we'd start producing more oil. we have the second most amount of oil in the world.... and by the time its done, there'll be many new forms of energy, or we'll be long gone on the planet. i see no reason to be buying foreign oil when we have slightly less than saudi arabia
Title: Re: Hello :)
Post by: vonDuTch on October 10, 2008, 04:47:43 PM
and i thought that you liked to bend over  :P